NUTLEY, NJ - This March, the Nutley real estate market continued to show its competitive nature as a diverse range of properties changed hands, reflecting the ongoing demand for homes in our community. Residents are drawn to town in part because of the wide variety of events that bring everyone together.

March started off with the annual St. Patrick's Day parade under sunny skies. The Nutley Irish American Association hosts the celebration of Irish American culture on the first Saturday in March. 

Another standout event in March was the Nutley Family Service Bureau’s Casino Night, an annual affair that brings the community together for a noble cause. Held at the Nutley Parks and Rec, this event featured an evening of games, music, and dining, all aimed at supporting the essential services provided by the Nutley Family Service Bureau. 

The Nutley High School Theatre Arts program hosted a production of “Mean Girls” the musical, Nutley Little Theatre hosted a readers' theater production of “The Cake,” and live music continued every weekend at the Oakley Kitchen and Cocktails. 

March’s Average List Price: $551,480

March’s Average Sales Price: $572,333

1. 454 River Rd, List Price: $285,000 , Sales Price: One Floor Unit, 1 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, 24 Days On Market

2. 458 River Rd, List Price: $339,000 , Sales Price: $290,000, First Floor Unit, 1 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, 111 Days On Market

3. 24 Union Ave, List Price: $319,000, Sales Price: $335,000, First Floor Unit, 1 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, 19 Days On Market 

4. 113 River Rd, List Price: $295,000, Sales Price:$350,000, Multi Floor Unit, 1 Bedroom, 1.1 Bathroom, 25 Days On Market

5. 108-110 Passaic Ave B-17, List Price: $500,000, Sales Price: $495,000, Multi Floor Unit , 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, 45 Days On Market 

6. 42 Cathedral Ave, List price: $499,900, Sales Price: $515,000, Colonial, 3 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom, 5 Days On Market

7. 95 Brookline Ave, List Price: $489,000, Sales Price: $540,000, Colonial, 3 Bedrooms, 1.5 Bathrooms, 11 Days On Market

8. 115 Alexander Ave, List Price:$540,000, Sales Price: $575,000, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, 14 Days On Market 

9. 39 Burnett Pl, List Price: $599,000, Sales Price:$615,000, Colonial, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Bathroom, 63 Days On Market

10. 71 Kierstead Ave, List Price: $669,900, Sales Price: $660,000, Cape Cod, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, 42 Days On Market

11. 10 Hickory Rd, List Price: $675,000, Sales Price: $715,000, Split Level, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, 19 Days On Market

12. 62 Kierstead Ave, List Price: $739,900, Sales Price: $755,000, 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bathrooms, 42 Days On Market

13. 115 Myrtle Ave, List Price: $787,500, Sales Price: $780,000, Colonial, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, 162 Days On Market 

14. 206 Hillside Avenue, List Price: $735,000, Sales Price: $840,000, Colonial, 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms, 9 Days On Market

15. 27 Pauline Dr, List Price: $799,000, Sales Price: $840,000, Colonial, 3 Bedroom, 2.2 Bathrooms, 22 Days On Market

This information is from the Garden State Multiple Listing Service Data: Single Family, Condominiums/Cooperatives, Townhouses March 1- March 31, 2025.

As we step into April, the outlook for Nutley’s real estate market is red-hot. With the community’s strong spirit and continued interest in local properties, Nutley is poised for another active season. 

Highlights of April include the return of the Nutley Department of Public Affairs Walking Club with walks taking place every Tuesday and Thursday at 6:30 am, the annual Vincent Church Rummage Sale, and the Dolores Capalbo Book Sale at the Nutley Public Library. Opening on April 11 is Nutley Little Theatre's production of ‘King Lear.’ Commissioner Mauro Tucci and the Department of Parks and Recreation host the annual Flashlight Egg Hunt on March 17 and the Easter Eggstravaganza on March 19. Get ready to party at the Van Riper Lawn Party on April 26. Find these and other events on the TAPinto Nutley Calendar of Events. 

For homeowners considering buying or selling, Zachary Sebek and the Zachary Sebek Group at Compass offer expert guidance and strategies that deliver results. The right approach can make all the difference.